Articles on the religious situation in India


  

 HOME

Past Articles: 2002

 
Burning the dead: Ancient Hindu ritual poses environmental crisis Pope calls for conversions in India
Muslim polygamy a mere myth: Survey  Does sperm have a religion?
Bollywood star not Hindu enough to play god Priest 'sacrifices' daughter
Muslim group boycotts Nanavati Commission Bhaur for new ways to propagate Sikhism
Religious Bias in India's Textbooks? VHP to launch reconversion drive in Kerala
Animal sacrifice in temples banned Non-Muslims persecuted in Bangladesh: Human Rights activist
Faithful Attend Indian Fests Despite Risks [Kumbha Mela] Monkey god's incarnation earns his keep at massive Indian pilgrimage [Kumbha Mela]
Archaeologists find Hindu temple under Indian mosque rubble  
   
   
   
   
   

 

 

Archaeologists find Hindu temple under Indian mosque rubble

(AFP, August 25, 2003)

Indian archaeologists have found a medieval Hindu temple under the remains of an Islamic shrine that was razed by Hindus in 1992 sparking deadly nationwide riots, a report unveiled in court showed.
Muslim leaders immediately vowed to challenge the study, which described a 10th century temple with Hindu carvings, that was found under the rubble of the Babri mosque in the northern town of Ayodhya.
More than a decade ago thousands of Hindu zealots pulled down the 16th century mosque saying it was built after a temple to their mythological warrior god Ram was destroyed.
The act sparked off nationwide Hindu-Muslims riots that left 2,000 people dead and became a key issue in the electoral campaign of the Hindu nationalist BJP party, which now heads the coalition government.
The dispute over the site is now in the hands of the courts which ordered the report by the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI).
Monday's release of the sensitive document was followed almost immediately by two car bomb blasts that killed at least 44 people and injured 100 in India's financial capital Bombay. It was not known if there was any connection.
A summary of the report, released by the court, said there was "archaeological evidence of a massive structure just below the disputed structure (the mosque) and evidence of continuity in structural phases from the 10th century onwards up to the construction of the disputed structure."
In the report, archaeologists said they found decorated bricks as well as a "mutilated sculpture of a divine couple", a circular shrine with a waterchute and 50 pillar bases with temple-style carvings including lotus motifs.
The lotus is a symbol associated with the Hindu religion, while waterchutes are seen usually only in Hindu temples.
These were "indicative of remains which are distinctive features found associated with the temples of the north," said the report.
ASI, a government body which cares for historical monuments, Friday handed over the sealed report on its excavations to the Lucknow High Court, which Monday held a closed-door hearing to study the findings.
Mohammad Shameem, one of the top lawyers representing the Muslims in the high-profile case, told AFP that people should not jump to conclusions about the mosque being positioned over a temple.
"Whatever structures have been found are located at least 150 feet (45 metres) away from the disputed site," Shameem told reporters after coming out of the hearing.
"It would be wrong to jump to conclusions."
Meanwhile, Zafaryab Jilani, convenor of the All India Babri Masjid Action Committee, a Muslim group that is a plaintiff in the case, said the ASI report was "vague and self-contradictory and prepared under political pressure."
"We have sought a month's time to go through the report after which we will file our objections," said Jilani, who also attended Monday's court hearing.
The court said it would grant both parties six weeks to file their objections to the findings of the ASI report.
ASI has declined to disclose the report's contents but others say it runs to 574 pages and contains substantial visual evidence.
The dig at India's most sensitive religious site began on March 12 and was supposed to be finished in a month, but the court granted ASI several extensions.

 

 

Monkey god's incarnation earns his keep at massive Indian pilgrimage

(AFP, August 29, 2003)

For Ram Das Gusain, who has a wife and two children to support, festivals are peak times for business. He believes he is an incarnation of the Hindu monkey god Hanuman -- and dresses and behaves accordingly.
Holy men seeking alms are frequenting the western Indian city of Nashik, which is packed with millions of Hindus coming for a sacred bath in an event being held here for the first time in more than 100 years.
Many pilgrims offer charity to the holy men, some naked, some with matted hair and flowing beards, and others clad in yellow robes and carrying tridents.
For Gusain, the connection to the monkey god stretches into every aspect of life. His diet consists mostly of bananas.
"I have more than 50 to 60 bananas every day. I have imbibed every trait of god Hanuman," he said with a smile as pilgrims dropped coins into his steel bowl.
Gusain paints his body orange and has a curling tail made of spiralling cloth tied to his waist.
The death of 45 devotees here Tuesday in a stampede at the Kumbh Mela, or Nectar Pot festival, during a sacred bathing ritual at a river has not shaken the 55-year-old holy man.
"It is a question of time. When each person's time is up then he dies," Gusain said. "I am a believer who is still alive and have to take care of my family and my stomach."
"I start my day by offering prayers to Hanuman," Gusain said. "Then I apply orange colour mixed with oil all over my body and put on the crown. I have taken this form because I believe in god."
Gusain greets every pilgrim by saying "Jai Ram," or "Long live the god Ram," and earns about 600 rupees (13 dollars) a day.
"I am married and have two kids. This money will help sustain my family," he said.
As he works, his family spends time around the temples. At night they all sleep on the street.
Gusain remains barefoot and walks about 15 kilometers (nine miles) daily.
"It is a long walk and I start everyday by about 10.00 am and end the day at about 3.00 pm," Gusain said. "Wherever a major festival happens in India I see to it that I spread the message of Hanuman and earn a living."
"I will be here (at the Kumbh Mela) for a week," he said. "I visit all the famous temples in India during the festivals."
The six-week Kumbh Mela is held every three years, rotating among four areas in India.
The bathing area at the Godavari river lies near the spot where the Hindu warrior god Ram, accompanied by his wife Sita and brother Laxman, is reputed to have spent his years in the jungles after being forced into exile by his father.
Devandas Maharaj came to Nashik from the Hindu kingdom of Nepal and said he has toured all of India's major temples. He travels with a 20-member entourage of holy men.
Financing his trip, he said, "is not much of a problem."
"I have never fallen short of money in any of the trips," Maharaj said. "When short of money we travel by bus or walk," he said. "When we are hungry we request a devotee to give some money."

 

Faithful Attend Indian Fests Despite Risks

by Neelesh Misra (AP, August 29, 2003)

Ever since they were newlyweds decades ago, Moti Ram and his wife, Kashi Bai, dreamed of bathing in a holy river during the Hindu Kumbh festival.
The elderly couple finally made it to the Kumbh — among the largest religious gatherings in the world — only to find themselves swept up in a stampede on Wednesday that killed 39 Hindu pilgrims.
Ram, 70, and his wife fell and would have been crushed if others had not pulled them to the banks of the Godavari River. But they expressed no regrets.
"Outsiders may not understand this, but we Hindus come here from all over the country because we want to seek our destiny and attain salvation," Bai, 65, said.
The couple and their 30-year-old son, Ram Phool Maina, who fractured his right arm in the stampede, traveled hundreds of miles in a packed train to reach Nasik.
"We were too poor to come, but we always dreamed about it, because we wanted to clean our sins and wash them away into the river," said Ram, a farmer in the central Indian state of Madhya Pradesh.
Some 60 million people journeyed to Nasik, 110 miles northeast of Bombay, this month, leaving behind their work, farms and shops to attend the Kumbh festival.
They come expecting inconveniences, such as sleeping in shanties and walking for miles in the sun, often without food or water. They know they might get separated from each other, hurt, or even killed in the festival. More than 750 people have been crushed or drowned at the event in the last two decades.
"We came here because it was destiny, and we survived because it was destiny," said Bai, wearing a brown printed sari as she visited her son in the city's government hospital on Thursday.
About 125 people were injured in Wednesday's riverside chaos; most of the dead were women who had been trampled.
Despite the potential heartache, the faithful still come.
"Many of those coming here are either poor people, or those who are anguished because of personal problems. Clinging to religion is the last resort for them," said university professor Madan Thapliyal, currently visiting friends in Nasik. He, too, went for a holy dip.
Although India has no state religion and a secular constitution, religious values run deep. More than 80 percent of India's 1 billion people are Hindus.
The Kumbh Mela, literally meaning "festival of the water pitcher," is held every 12 years, timed in connection with the alignments of the sun and Jupiter. The main festival is held near the northern holy city of Allahabad, while the Nasik festival is one of the "mini-kumbhs" held more often.
The Kumbh Mela originates from an ancient Hindu myth revolving around a joint effort by gods and demons to churn the oceans and attain immortality. The churning brought about a pitcher of "amrit," or nectar — and the two sides began squabbling over it.
In the melee, according to legend, the pitcher spilled and the four places where it dropped on earth are those where Kumbh festivals are held.
Millions of devout — from villagers in turbans to Indian movie stars — jostle and rush to the ghats, or riverside bathing areas. They chant mantras, shed clothes and leap into the water. Those who can't swim stand waist deep, scooping up water and pouring it over their heads in a centuries-old gesture.
They believe a dip will purify them — and are indifferent to the pollution in India's rivers.
The childless want children; relatives seek good health for ailing kin; and the elderly desire salvation from Hinduism's endless cycle of reincarnation.
Mark Twain, who visited the Kumbh festival in the 1890s, wrote: "The power of faith like that can make multitudes of the old and the weak and the young and the frail to enter without hesitation or complaint."

 

Non-Muslims persecuted in Bangladesh: Human Rights activist

(“PTI,” August 27, 2003)

Accusing Bangladesh of persecuting the minorities, a prominent Human Rights activist has said attacks on non-Muslims have increased since October 2001, when the Bangladesh National Party came to power in a coalition with hardline Islamic parties.
Director of Hotline Bangladesh, Rosaline Costa, a former nun, now visiting US, told The Washington Times that Bangladesh is now a land of terror for many of its Hindu, Buddhist and Christian citizens.
She told the paper that in the Bhola islands on the southern coast of the country, 98 per cent of Hindu women interviewed "had been raped by Muslim thugs."
Costa pointed out that before partition non-Muslims had made up 33 per cent of the population. They now number only 9.9 per cent. Thousands of people have fled to India, Japan and other countries, especially Britain.
The Washington Times points out that Amnesty International and the State Department too have condemned the abuses in Bangladesh though the State Department says that the Government "generally respected" religious freedom.
Costa, contradicting the State Department's stand, said that local police do little or nothing to investigate the attacks.
Sitangshu Guha, a Hindu-American accompanying her in her tour, said Bangladesh has become a breeding ground for militant Islam.
Friday afternoons, said Costa, who lives near one of the largest mosques in Bangladesh, are the worst.
She alleged that angry Muslims, inflamed by mullahs at Friday services, pour out of the mosque, looking for any available Christian, Hindu or Buddhist on whom to vent their fury.
The situation, she said, was worse in the rural areas. There, Muslim mobs have "ethnically cleansed" many areas of their non-Muslim inhabitants. Hindus are the most affected, she said, because they traditionally have owned the most land.
"Rape," said Costa, "is a most useful tool to evict a family. Rape makes it impossible for a family to stay in the area," she said, explaining that the female victims were frequently blamed for disgracing their families.

Animal sacrifice in temples banned

(The Hindu, August 28, 2003)

In another initiative pleasing to animal rights activists, the Tamil Nadu Government today banned animal and bird sacrifice in temples throughout the State.
This is the second time in three days the Chief Minister, Jayalalithaa, has intervened in the interest of animals put to suffering in temples.
On Tuesday, she ordered that temple elephants be given a one-month holiday every year.
The Chief Minister has now written to District Collectors, Superintendents of Police and range Deputy Inspectors-General, asking them to prevent the killing of animals in the name of propitiating gods. Stringent action should be taken against violators, she told them.
Tracing the events which led to her intervention, an official release said about 500 buffaloes were sacrificed at a village temple near Tiruchi recently.
The event, which took place right in front of the Deputy Superintendent of Police, who was in charge of the security of the area, was brought to the notice of the Chief Minister, who ordered the Director-General of Police to place the DSP under suspension.
In her letter to the district authorities, she pointed out that the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1950, and its subsequent amendment, banned the killing of animals and birds in temples and on their premises.
She told the authorities to advise and prevent people from indulging in such cruel acts to seek the blessings of Gods. Offenders would have to be dealt with sternly, she said.
In recent weeks, cow slaughter and animal rights became politicised following a proposal to bring in a bill in Parliament to ban cow slaughter.
While Ms. Jayalalithaa expressed herself in favour of the Bill, the DMK president, M. Karunanidhi, opposed the measure, saying it was discriminatory.
He said if it all a ban were to be imposed, it should cover all animals.

 

VHP to launch reconversion drive in Kerala

(Kerala News, August 28, 2003)

KOCHI: Encouraged by the overwhelming response to its reconversion drive in some North Indian States, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad is all set to attempt a similar movement in Kerala.
'Dharma Prasar,' a VHP outfit which spearheaded the drive in selected states, will chalk out its Kerala strategies at its three-day national meet slated to begin here on August 29.
A communiqué detailing the project has been sent to NSS, SNDP and Devaswom Boards. Sources said the initial feedback from the Devaswom Board has been quite encouraging.
Meanwhile, the Dharma Prasar has made elaborate groundwork in Kerala as a prelude to its drive in line with the modus operandi of Christian missionaries.
Its "missionaries" have already begun their works in Idukki district, one of the most potential areas identified by its research team.
According to Dr Puthezhathu Ramachandran, the VHP's national vice-president, they have already deputed six missionaries in the interiors of Idukki who regularly hold Sunday gatherings at Pampanar Sri Subramania Temple in Peermedu.
"We have also plans to open "Ekal Vidyalayas" in selected districts in the State, in addition to launching several social service projects, including opening of orphanages across the State," he said.
Maintaining that the movement was not aimed at reconversion but to facilitate "home coming" of the "transgressed sect," Dr Ramachandran said "there is a demand for self-preservation of the Hindu society from the grassroots. The Kochi meet will prepare a blueprint of Kerala operations."
According to him, the Dharma Prasar's mission has proved a great success in the Christian-dominated Jharkhand, Chattisgarh, and a few districts in Rajasthan.
The VHP has already opened its missionary training centre at Peermedu.
"Our idea is to train at least 10 missionaries every six months. We know our mission requires large resources. But going by the initial response we feel that funds would not be a constraint to carry out the agenda. Several religious institutions, including all Devaswom Boards, have offered their total co-operation to our historic venture," said another top VHP leader.
"Like any other State in India, a major section of Dalit Christians in Kerala feels that it is being discriminated by the Church. The promises given to it by the Churches have not been fulfilled. The Dalits feel cheated. The Kochi meet will chalk out strategies that would enable them to embrace their ancestral tradition," said Mohan Joshi, VHP's central secretary who is here to attend the meet.
Over 100 top leaders of VHP from various states, including Acharya Giriraj Kishore, R Vedantham, and Mohan Joshi will attend the three-day meet.


Religious Bias in India's Textbooks?

(“UPI,” August 21, 2003)

Critics say government's religious agenda shows through in books' treatment of beef-eating, caste, non-Hindus, history & more
A top Indian minister recently said the country's scientific community should shed its skepticism and use astrology to predict earthquakes and other natural disasters.
"It ... (is) scientific fundamentalism to dismiss warnings from Indian astrologers," said Murli Manohar Joshi, India's Human Resources and Development minister. He was inaugurating a workshop on "Predicting Earthquakes and Calamities" in New Delhi. "Scientists with advanced computers sometimes fail to predict major earthquakes," he said. "Ancient Indian astrology does have the tools to roughly foretell the time and sometimes even the exact date and time of an earthquake."
Last year, Joshi proposed that astrology be introduced in schools, and at least one state government has begun offering the subject. The trend, critics say, is an attempt by the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party to impose its Hindu nationalist agenda on the country.
Last year, the Indian government made a series of changes to high school history textbooks, prompting criticism from opponents who said the amendments reflected the ruling BJP's pro-Hindu policies.
The BJP, however, denies this. The textbooks, it says, offended religious sentiment and were written by left-leaning academics. The changes, it says, represent a more nationalistic portrayal of events. It also labeled previous history texts as having a Western bias.
Under the Constitution, India is a secular state and, like the United States, endorses no one religion. The country, however, is overwhelmingly Hindu. The Indian government's 2001 census, the most-recent data available, shows Hindus make up 82 percent of the country's population; Muslims follow with 12.12 percent; and Christians with 2.34 percent. The numbers--even relatively small percentages--are significant because of India's population--1 billion people.
The country is ruled by the National Democratic Alliance -- a coalition of more than two dozen parties, not all of them religion- oriented, that is headed by the BJP. The BJP has ties to militant Hindu groups and some of its leaders have been accused of crimes against religious minorities.
Human-rights groups have noted that militant Hindu groups have stepped up attacks on minorities since the BJP took office at the federal level in 1998.
There have been sporadic attacks against Christian missionaries and the southern state of Tamil Nadu, ruled by a BJP ally, passed a law that bans what it calls "forced conversions." Religious riots in the western state of Gujarat last year killed more than 1,000 people, the vast majority of them Muslim.
Critics--mostly left-leaning academics, the country's opposition parties and non-governmental organizations--say the new religious agenda can be seen most clearly in education.
Last year's changes in textbooks prescribed by the National Council for Educational Research and Training, the federal-level body that controls education in thousands of schools across the country, are a case in point.
References to beef eating, which is prohibited by Hinduism, and cattle sacrifices were deleted. Also cut were a critical evaluation of ancient Hindu religious texts and epics on the basis of archaeological and epigraphic testimony; the opposition of Brahmans, the priestly class in the four-fold caste system, to the Buddhist King Ashoka, who is regarded as one of India's greatest rulers; and references to the exploitative aspects of the caste system. References to the early life of the founder of the Jain religion were also removed
Details of the execution of Sikh Guru Tegh Bahadur by Muslim rulers were deleted. Another reference to the plundering by the Jat community rulers of the area Bharatpur was also taken out.
The government officially said nothing. But NCERT on its Web site listed praise from some of those communities that deemed the passages offensive.
NCERT said the passages offended the Sikhs, Jain and Jat sentiments. Hindus were also offended, it says, by the references to cow sacrifice and beef eating, and by the passages on archeological and epigraphic evidence.
The deletion of passages referring to Brahmin hostility and the caste system were not explained.
The issue remains controversial but is unlikely to change. Last December, the country's Supreme Court ruled that the changes were legitimate.
Criticism against the BJP and its education policy is not new. In the early 1990s, when the party first came into prominence and took over a number of state governments, its history and social studies curriculum was condemned.
In the BJP-ruled Gujarat state, for instance, high school textbooks praised Hindu culture to the detriment of others. The social studies textbook for the ninth-grade equivalent class all but lauded the much-derided caste system. "The Varna system was a precious gift of the Aryans to the mankind," it said, referring to the four-tier caste hierarchy. " ... The importance of the ' Varna' system as an ideal system of building the social and economic structure of a society cannot be overlooked."
The book was also not very flattering to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, the term used to refer to the lowest tier of the caste system and the so-called untouchables. In a section titled "Problems of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes," the authors say: "Of course, their ignorance, illiteracy and blind faith are to be blamed for lack of progress because they fail to realize the importance of education in life."
Whether the book was biased is debatable, but the factual errors in it are not. In its chapter, "Problems of the Country and Their Solutions," the book has a subheading that reads "Minority Community." In it, Muslims, Christians and Parsees -- members of a Zoroastrian sect -- are all labeled "foreigners." " ... (A )part from the Muslims, even the Christians, Parsees and other foreigners are also recognized as the minority communities," the book says. "In most states, the Hindus are in a minority and Muslims, Christians and Sikhs are in majority."
The last statement is incorrect because as per the 1991 census Hindus were the majority by a substantial margin in 21 of 26 states.
In the 10th-grade equivalent history textbook, the issue of the Holocaust is completely glossed over and Nazism is referred to with veiled admiration. "Hitler lent dignity and prestige to the German government within a short time by establishing a strong administrative set up ... He adopted the policy of opposition towards the Jewish people," it says. " ... He adopted a new economic policy and brought prosperity to Germany ... He made untiring efforts to make Germany self-reliant within one decade ... He instilled the spirit of adventure in the common people."
In the western state of Maharashtra, south of Gujarat, a college-level history text refers to India's largest minority, the Muslims, thus: "The advent of Islam might have been a boon to the Arabs who got united under its banner ... but it has been a curse for the people outside Arab world because wherever the Islamic hordes went, they not only conquered the countries, but killed millions of people and plundered their homes and places of worship and destroyed their homes, places of worship and above all their artworks," it says. It adds: "Why these atrocities? Because Islam teaches only atrocities." After Indonesia, India has the second-largest Muslim population in the world. Despite the criticism, the BJP is strong and is seen to have a reasonable chance to retain power in the general election, dates for which are expected soon.
Whether the BJP wins, however, the fight over textbooks is likely to stay.

 
 

Muslim group boycotts Nanavati Commission

by Sukrat Desai ("Indo-Asian News Service," July 16, 2003)

The Nanavati Commission, probing last year's sectarian violence in Gujarat, started its hearings in Ahmedabad on Wednesday under a cloud of controversy with a prominent Muslim organization boycotting the proceedings.

"Our stand has been clear from the day Justice KG Shah was inducted into the commission. We knew that justice would elude us," chairperson of the Gujarat chapter of the Jamaat-e-Islami, Mohammed Safi Madni said.

The group, which has been involved in relief work, is currently engaged in helping rehabilitate the riot victims.

As the two-member commission began hearing depositions of the riot victims, there were others who expressed their lack of faith in it.

Senior High Court advocate Mohsin Quadri said it was a state government tool.

"The commission is the state government's tool to collect evidence in support of the perpetrators of the communal violence," Quadri alleged.

The two-member commission, headed by retired Justice GT Nanavati, has been entrusted with the task of investigating the causes of last year's riots, which killed at least 1,000 people.

The hearings in Ahmedabad, the last stop before the commission completes its investigation, are considered particularly crucial because the city accounted for about half of the killings.


In the first phase of the hearings until July 22, the commission will hear only those from the predominantly Hindu neighbourhoods of western Ahmedabad.

It is only in the second phase, scheduled to begin from July 28, when the commission will investigate the killings in Naroda-Patia and Gulbarg Society -- 85 people were killed in Naroda-Patia and 39, including former Congress parliamentarian Ehsan Jafri, in Gulbarg Society in eastern Ahmedabad.

Thus, the riot victims of two of the most brutal incidents in last year's violence will have to wait before they get a chance to depose.

Human rights activists pointed out that only incidents of looting of Muslim property and minor skirmishes were reported from western Ahmedabad. The major incidents of violence occurred in the eastern Ahmedabad, which has a mixed population of Hindus and Muslims.

But controversy is not new for the commission.

Two months ago in May, Nanavati created a storm when he gave a clean chit to the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government. He said the government had no role to play in the communal violence and there was no clinching evidence available against it.

This was despite several rights groups and victims who said the state government had actively colluded with rightwing Hindu groups in the riots.

Following the widely criticized statement, the commission's hearing in Vadodara last month was boycotted by several NGOs and civil liberties groups.

The commission began its hearing last year from Godhra, from where the riots had sparked off after the killing of 59 train passengers.

The commission has so far held hearings in 22 of the 25 districts and received more than 4,000 representations from the riot victims narrating incidents of violence.

 

 
 
Priest 'sacrifices' daughter
("The Hindu," July 17, 2003) 

A priest allegedly murdered his daughter to appease his goddess at Madlehalli in Tiptur taluk of Tumkur district recently.

Narayanappa, a priest at the Chowdeshwari Temple at Dasarighatta, took his daughter, Ambika (12), to Tiptur on the last new moon day (June 29) on the pretext
of buying her textbooks.But the next day, he returned home without her.His wife, Gowramma, who suspected foul play, lodged a police complaint about the missing girl
after a week.

Police found the body of Ambika at Galibande hillock about one km away from Madlehalli on Wednesday. Her head was tonsured.There were signs of sacrificial
rites at the spot. Her plaited hair was also found at a distance.

The Deputy Superintendent of Police, L. Shivashankar, visited the spot. The priest is reported to be absconding.

 

 
 
Bollywood star not Hindu enough to play god
("SAPA-AFP," July 18, 2003)

Salman Khan, Bollywood's bad boy, has dropped plans to play the role of the Hindu god Lord Rama after receiving threats allegedly from Hindu hardliners, according to his personal friend Bunty Walia.

Khan, 37, who has been in the news for beating girlfriends and a fatal hit-and-run controversy, announced earlier this year that he was to star as Lord Rama in the big-budget Ramayana.

"He (Khan) as well as I have received a number of threats from certain people, following which we have decided not to make the movie, at least for now," said Walia.

The Asian Age newspaper reported that Khan, a Muslim, had received threats from the Hindu right-wing group Bajrang Dal for taking the role.

"We had started pre-production work on the film, but there are some people who think that I should not play Rama because I am a Muslim," the report quoted Khan as saying.

"How can people forget that my mother is a Hindu? And if my mother had not been there, how would I be here today? It is frustrating and sad, but what can I do?"

Walia said the project was being kept in abeyance and might be revived later.

Ramayana was to be produced by Khan and Walia's production company, GS Entertainment, with a budget of more than 1,0 billion rupees (R167-million).

 

Bhaur for new ways to propagate Sikhism
("The Tribune," July 6, 2003)
 
Jathedar Sukhdev Singh Bhaur, a former acting SGPC president and an Akali stalwart, today underlined the need for new methods for propagation of Sikhism to usher in a renaissance in the Sikh religion and to bring back those who had got weaned away from the faith. He was addressing the 86th “Jor Mela” at nearby historic Palahi village on the concluding day. The three day “Jor Mela” was held to observe the fifth battle fought by the sixth Guru Hargobind, against the Mughal rulers at Palahi village in 1634.
Jathedar Bhaur told the congregation that he was not satisfied with the traditional ways of propagation of Sikhism, confined to the gurdwara.

The emergence of godmen like Baba Ashutosh and Piara Singh Bhaniara, the episode at Talhan, the distribution of trishuls and lathis were stagemanaged to erode Sikhism, which championed the cause of humanity, he said. He also held that the satellite channels responsible for diluting spiritual values. He attributed the present plight of Sikhism to the penchant for taking religious preachings casually.

The Punjab Social Welfare Minister, Mr Joginder Singh Mann, while addressing the congregation, eulogised Guru Hargobind as the author of the concept of saint-soldier. Sikhism stood for the well-being of one and all, added Mr Mann. Both Jathedar Bhaur and Mr Mann were honoured with siropas. Noted ‘Dhadi’ singers included Swaran Singh Maheru, Jawala Singh Patanga, Jaswant Singh Josh and Ram Singh Raftar. 
 

 

 
Burning the dead: Ancient Hindu ritual poses environmental crisis
(AP, July 14, 2003)
 
       Tears rolling down his face, Bachchan Singh Bahadur poured cups of melted butter on the wood fire of his father's funeral pyre on the outskirts of New Delhi.
       He was in keeping with a centuries-old Hindu funeral     tradition, but it's also the stuff of ecological nightmares for the Indian government.
The 35-year-old government clerk could have used an electricity-powered crematorium less than half a mile away for just one-tenth of the price, but for him nothing would do except a wood-burning crematorium by the Yamuna River where the ashes would be tossed after cooling overnight.
       ''Unless the body is burned on a wood pyre, the soul does not get salvation,'' he explained. ''When the flames leap up to heaven, then you get the satisfaction the soul is set free.''
       Nearly 20,000 Hindus die each day in this nation of 1 billion people. Each cremation requires an average of 650 pounds of wood. The result is denuded forests, rivers clogging up with human ashes — or even body parts — and a wood trade said to be rife with corruption.
       In the 1980s the government turned to electric furnaces, building scores of them in cities and towns along the Ganges River, whose waters are believed by Hindus to wash away sin and release the soul for its journey toward heaven.
       But few Hindus have made the changes, and many of the electric crematoriums have fallen into disrepair.
       One problem is frequent power outages.
       ''People don't have much faith in the electric crematorium. When the power goes off, the body can lie in the machine for hours. How can we heap such indignities on the dead?'' said Ramesh Gupta, a shopkeeper attending the last rites for a relative at a New Delhi cremation ground.
       ''Imagine the distress to the family.''
       The bereaved are at the mercy, however, of a cartel of wood traders.
       Some officials say wood traders collude with operators of the electric crematoriums to ensure that the furnaces malfunction or run short of diesel for their generators.
       ''They deliberately don't let the crematoriums function so that hapless people are forced to buy wood from them at exorbitant prices,'' said B. Sengupta, of the government's Central Pollution Control Board.
       Varanasi, the holy city on the Ganges 395 miles southeast of New Delhi, attracts hundreds of thousands of people who cremate their dead and pour the ashes into the river to ensure ''moksha,'' the final liberation of the soul from the endless cycle of reincarnation.
       The ashes of millions of dead have helped turn the water into a stinking, polluted swirl. Worse, since wood is scarce and expensive, bodies sometimes are thrown into the river half-burned.
       ''Apart from the ashes, this is an even bigger environmental hazard for the Ganges River,'' said Sunita Narain, an activist with the Center for Science and Environment in New Delhi.
       Environmentalists prefer electric furnaces because they don't need wood and they reduce the body to a small urnful of powdery ash that does less harm to the rivers.
       Swami Agnivesh, a Hindu theologian and social activist, says the religion is flexible enough to accept technology. ''Many Hindus would welcome the change, especially if they were made aware of the environmental consequences of wood cremation,'' he said.
       New Delhi has 58 wood-burning cremation parks, like the one Bahadur was using, and four electric facilities. The government wants to build 13 more such furnaces in the capital, but environmentalists question whether it can supply the power to guarantee uninterrupted service.
       A cremation at New Delhi's Nigambodh Ghat electric facility costs about $4, compared with $40 for a wood-log cremation.
       Agnivesh said the government should do more to highlight the savings.
       ''The beauty of Hinduism is that it is not a die-hard philosophy,'' he said. ''However, people have to be convinced before they make a change.''


 

 
 
Pope calls for conversions in India
("The Tablet," July 12, 2003) 
 
 On 3 July, the Pope told bishops on their ad limina visit to the Vatican that Christianity separated from a proclamation of Jesus as the only Saviour “is no longer Christian”.

“Any theology of mission that omits the call to a radical conversion to Christ and denies the cultural transformation that such conversion will entail necessarily misrepresents the reality of our faith, which is always a new beginning in the life of him who alone is the way, the truth and the life”, John Paul II said.

The Pope cited “ample evidence” in the bishops’ reports that the Church’s missionary efforts in India were taking root. He noted numerous adult baptisms despite social obstacles faced especially by aspiring converts who are poor, the high percentage of Catholics who attend Sunday Mass, and increasing numbers of laity “properly participating” in the liturgy.

The issue of conversions is controversial in India, where right-wing Hindu organisations accuse Christians of seeking to convert Hindus by force. Six states have passed conversion laws, which Hindu groups say protect poor Indians against forced conversions and which Christians say are discriminatory and curtail religious freedom. Last month, the Pope expressed his concerns about India’s conversion laws, provoking a barrage of criticism from Hindu groups and a prominent politician.

At its annual gathering earlier this month, India’s most prominent right-wing Hindu group again accused the Pope of interfering in Indian affairs. The Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS), which has close ties with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) which leads the country’s coalition adminstration, demanded that the central government “lodge a protest” with the Pope. It warned that India’s legacy of tolerance should not be construed as a licence to others “to infringe on our national ethos and disturb peace”. The issue dominated discussionsat the group’s two-day meeting in Kanyakumari, a town on India’s southernmost tip.

In Rome, Archbishop Ignatius Pinto of Bangalore told the Pope that many non-Christians in India “would love to come into the fold, but the fear of social ostracism, deprivation of hereditary rights and privileges and other similar benefits keep them from embracing Christianity”.

Christians account for two per cent of the overwhelmingly Hindu population of India
 

 


 
Muslim polygamy a mere myth: Survey
by Rathin Das ("The Hindustan Times," July 12, 2003)
Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi may have jibed at Muslims during his 'Gaurav Yatra' last year by saying the fruits of development are neutralised by those who believe in 'hum paanch, hamare pachchis' (we five, our 25). Perhaps he didn't know what he had said is pure myth.

A survey conducted in Muslim-dominated areas of Ahmedabad stands contrary to the general belief surrounding the community's alleged polygamous tendencies, the staple diet of the Sangh Parivar's diatribe.

The survey, conducted in 1993, found that only two persons had four wives, two others had three wives and 279 had two wives. The survey covered eight blocks in the old city and some other areas, which together account for almost the entire Muslim population of Ahmedabad.

While Muslims have often been jeered, that fact is that Hindus are also involved in polygamous practices. As many as 29,951 cases of 'Maitri Karar’ (friendship contract) were found officially registered at the District Collectorate at that time. The Maitri Karar was a pact between a married Hindu man and his 'other woman' to circumvent provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act that prohibits another marriage while the wife is still alive, said sources in the legal fraternity.

"It was not legally enforceable, but the Maitri Karar was meant to give a sense of security to the married man's 'other woman'," said lawyer Girish Patel.

Among the Muslims too, the survey— conducted by the Gujarat affiliate of MARG— found that most of the second marriages could be attributed basically to extra-marital affairs, which were legitimised taking advantage of the Shariat laws.

In few cases, the second marriage was solemnised as the first wife was unable to bear a child, said former corporator J.V. Momin. Momin had ordered the survey in the wake of intense criticism from the Sangh on this score soon after the Babri Masjid demolition.

Some cases of second marriage among the Muslims emanated from the need to provide security to widowed sister-in-laws.

 
 
Does sperm have a religion?
 
("The Sydney Morning Herald," July 14, 2003)

It's not the physical attributes or medical history of sperm donors that worry many Indian couples opting for assisted reproduction.

Their main concern is religion, a report said yesterday.

Infertility specialists in the western city of Bombay said two in every 10 couples contemplating in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) insisted on knowing the religion of the donor, the Asian Age newspaper reported.

Gynaecologist Hrishikesh Pai said: "Recently a couple insisted the sperm be from a Catholic donor. After a lot of counselling, they agreed to a general donor. Muslims, too, are particular about the religion of the donor."

One couple from the Parsi community decided to remain childless after their request for a Parsi donor was turned down, the report said.

Another doctor, Nandita Palshetkar, said: "A Parsi man had a very low sperm count. He was adamant the donor be Parsi. We tried our best but they would not listen to us. The husband refused IVF for his wife, saying it was better not to have a baby."

Dr Pai said: "What is the religion of the sperm or egg? It's not possible to get donors of a particular caste or religion. Couples going for IVF must not be biased."

In one case, a Hindu vegetarian couple insisted the donor also be vegetarian, the report said.

 

 

 HOME

Past Articles: 2002